AAPLLoadingMSFTLoadingNVDALoadingGOOGLLoadingAMZNLoadingMETALoadingTSLALoadingAMDLoadingNFLXLoadingCOINLoadingPYPLLoadingSPYLoadingQQQLoadingIWMLoadingJPMLoadingVLoadingDISLoadingKOLoadingJNJLoadingNKELoadingXOMLoadingASMLLoading
FreeSCHW3 min read

Cash sorting is a deposit franchise being repriced by its own customers

It traded at 92.92, +0.59% on the session. A brokerage looks like a fee business and earns a surprising amount of its money the way a bank does.

SCHW
Delayed

Where the money actually comes from

When a client leaves cash in a brokerage account, the firm can hold it on its own balance sheet and invest it. The client receives a modest rate. The firm earns the difference, and across a very large client base that difference is a major earnings line.

The arrangement depends on clients not paying much attention to the rate on idle cash. For long stretches that is exactly what happens, because the balance is small relative to the portfolio and moving it is a chore. When rates on alternatives become conspicuous, clients move the money into funds that pay more, often inside the same account.

That migration is the risk, and it is not driven by a recession or a credit cycle. It is driven by clients noticing.

What I watch

  • The share of client assets sitting in cash against its own history, since an unusually high share is the fuel for a migration
  • Net new assets, which say whether the franchise is still winning relationships
  • The gap between what the firm pays on cash and what a money fund pays, because that gap is the incentive
  • Interest-earning balances rather than total assets, since the second can grow while the first shrinks

A deposit franchise is a habit. It earns well until the habit becomes expensive enough to notice.

Where I stand

Flat. The business is a genuinely strong gatherer of assets, and the cash question is a headwind rather than a flaw. I have no confident view on when clients collectively decide to pay attention, and without that the timing is guesswork.

What would change my mind

Cash balances stabilising at a low share of assets while net new assets keep growing. That would mean the migration has already happened and the franchise kept the relationships through it, which is the version of this story worth paying for.

The author holds no position in the instruments discussed. Opinion. Not advice. Not a financial promotion approved under FSMA s.21. Quote data is delayed. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Comments

0 comments
Sign in to comment.

No comments yet

Be the first to weigh in.