AAPLLoadingMSFTLoadingNVDALoadingGOOGLLoadingAMZNLoadingMETALoadingTSLALoadingAMDLoadingNFLXLoadingCOINLoadingPYPLLoadingSPYLoadingQQQLoadingIWMLoadingJPMLoadingVLoadingDISLoadingKOLoadingJNJLoadingNKELoadingXOMLoadingASMLLoading
FreeMCO4 min read

A ratings agency sells something nobody wants to buy and everybody must

The shares last traded at 464.18, -1.96% on the session. This is a business I admire for a reason that sounds like a criticism: its customers would rather not pay for the product.

MCO
Delayed

Why the product is compulsory

An issuer does not buy a rating because it wants an opinion on its own credit. It buys one because the investors it needs are required, by mandate or regulation, to hold rated paper, and because rated debt prices better than unrated debt. The rating is a ticket, and only a few places sell tickets.

That is an unusual position. Demand does not depend on the customer valuing the product. It depends on the rest of the market continuing to require it, and that requirement is written into a great many documents.

What drives the numbers

  • Debt issuance volumes, which are cyclical and sensitive to rates and spreads
  • Refinancing schedules, which bring issuance forward whatever the cycle is doing
  • The analytics and data business, which is recurring and smooths the ratings cycle
  • Pricing, which has room because the fee is small relative to the cost of the debt it helps place

A toll that is a small fraction of the transaction, and required by the rules of the road, is about as good as tolls get.

Where I stand

Long, and patient about it. Issuance goes through slow years, and the ratings business will look weak in them. The structure does not change in a slow year, and the recurring side keeps growing underneath.

What would change my mind

Regulation that loosens the requirement to hold rated paper, or a credible alternative that the largest investors accept. This moat is written into the rules, and the rules are the thing to watch.

The author holds no position in the instruments discussed. Opinion. Not advice. Not a financial promotion approved under FSMA s.21. Quote data is delayed. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Comments

0 comments
Sign in to comment.

No comments yet

Be the first to weigh in.