AAPLLoadingMSFTLoadingNVDALoadingGOOGLLoadingAMZNLoadingMETALoadingTSLALoadingAMDLoadingNFLXLoadingCOINLoadingPYPLLoadingSPYLoadingQQQLoadingIWMLoadingJPMLoadingVLoadingDISLoadingKOLoadingJNJLoadingNKELoadingXOMLoadingASMLLoading
FreeDIA3 min read

Price weighting is an accident that became a benchmark

The fund last traded at 523.10, -0.33% on the session. This is the index most people have heard of and the one fewest people have looked inside.

DIA
Delayed

What price weighting actually does

Most indices weight their members by market value, so a company's influence reflects its size. This one weights by share price. A company whose shares happen to trade at a high number carries more weight than a far larger company whose shares trade at a low one.

Nothing about a share price says anything about a company. It is the market value divided by a share count the company chose, and a split changes it without changing the business at all. So the index's weights are partly a record of corporate housekeeping decisions made over decades.

Why it survives anyway

  • It is old, and a long continuous history is genuinely useful even when the construction is odd
  • Its members are large, profitable and widely held, so it correlates closely with broader measures most of the time
  • A small, hand-picked membership makes it easy to describe, which is most of its public role
  • The oddities are well documented rather than hidden, which is more than can be said for some newer schemes

An index is a set of decisions about weight. The famous ones are not famous for making good decisions.

Where I stand

Flat, and this is a preference rather than a warning. The holdings are fine businesses. The weighting adds a source of movement unrelated to any of them, and I would rather own the same exposure without it.

What would change my mind

Very little, honestly. This is a construction question and the construction is not going to change. If the distortion ever pushed the index far enough from broader measures to create a genuine valuation gap, that would be a different conversation.

The author holds no position in the instruments discussed. Opinion. Not advice. Not a financial promotion approved under FSMA s.21. Quote data is delayed. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Comments

0 comments
Sign in to comment.

No comments yet

Be the first to weigh in.