It last traded at 153.60, +0.29% on the session. Retailers talk about traffic, brand heat and the customer. The inventory line says what they actually expected, and it is much harder to spin.
TGT
Delayed
Why inventory is the honest number
Orders are placed months before the goods arrive. So inventory today is a record of what management believed about demand a season ago, made with real money. If it has grown faster than sales, somebody was more optimistic than the customer turned out to be.
That gap does not stay on the balance sheet. It moves to the income statement as markdowns a quarter or two later, and it arrives looking like a margin problem when it was a forecasting one.
What I compare
Inventory growth against sales growth, the simplest test in retail and still the most useful
The discretionary share of the mix, since that is what gets marked down hardest
Gross margin guidance against the inventory position, because the two have to reconcile eventually
Freight and shrink, which can move margin for reasons unrelated to demand
A retailer can explain a weak quarter. It cannot explain a warehouse.
Why I am flat
A general merchandise retailer with a heavy discretionary mix is the first place a consumer slowdown shows up, and the first place a recovery shows up too. Without a clear read on which way the inventory gap is moving, it is a bet on the consumer at one remove, and I would rather watch the consumer directly.
What would change my mind
Inventory falling faster than sales for a couple of quarters, with margin guidance holding. That is a retailer that has cleared its shelves and can buy fresh at full price, which is the setup worth a view.
The author holds no position in the instruments discussed. Opinion. Not advice. Not a financial promotion approved under FSMA s.21. Quote data is delayed. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.
Comments
0 commentsNo comments yet
Be the first to weigh in.